Saturday, February 26, 2011

Enter the World of the Dream

During Friday’s class, Dr. Layne covered Descartes’ First Meditation. I found Descartes’ philosophy that the senses constantly deceive us about the nature of reality quite fascinating; especially when applied to the world of the dream. His argument makes perfect sense when one realizes that even in dreams there is an eerie likeness of real things (e.g. the world, space, color, and math). In order to show that science rested on foundations that lay in the mind and not the senses, Descartes began by asserting the importance of doubt; the foundation of knowing. I found Descartes’ claim extremely relatable (more so than “The Matrix”) to Christopher Nolan's movie “Inception” which deals with the fictional science of shared dreaming. The characters enter others' minds, to steal ideas, or plant them while the target is unaware they are dreaming. In the movie, characters can distinguish a dream from reality by using totems. In the end, the film leaves open the question of whether the protagonist (Cobb) is himself dreaming. The entire point of the architect character (Ariadne) is to meticulously design a world to deceive the subject’s ability to distinguish what’s real and what is not. "Inception" conveys Descartian philosophy.


Cause and Effect

An inductive argument draws from a general conclusion, and essentially poses a cause and effect like response. For instance, if you only have seen white swans, you would assume all swans are white. If you walk into a room and hit the light switch and the light comes on, then obviously the two are connected. Much like Hume, I would argue that cause and effect isn't necessarily the answer - but rather based off of habit.

For instance, when Pavlov did the bell experiment with the dogs (when you rang the bell, the dogs would come because they knew that there would be food) it was simply the idea of training the mind to think that when you hear a bell, food must be near. If you rang a bell at a passing dog, it may not do anything besides just stare at you blankly. But, for instance, if you trained a dog to run when a bell rang, the dog would run.

Essentially, Pavlov's experiment, and Hume's argument both supply amble amount of reason to believe that cause and effect aren't solely inherent, but rather based off of experience, and a sense of "training" your brain to understand something.

What is God; Via Negativa

I find the concept of via negatativa to be unusual. The definition of anything cannot be what it is not or it is in fact not a definition. To define something it must be clearly outlined. To say that we only know what God is not is not knowing what God is. And furthermore, how are we certain of what God is not? Is there some sort of proof for the notion that God is simple rather than complex? Are these not merely the speculations of men? Via Negative is not a solid argument for proveing exactly what God is.

Friday, February 25, 2011

Corporeal?

For me, I always put God in some kind of form or figure. Not necessarily to make God corporeal, but just so I can feel as though I am relating to something tangible. It is hard to think of God via negative sometimes. People have always put God into some category (if that makes since). For example, saying or writing “he” when referring to God specifics God is a male. If God is not corporeal how can we classify God has “he”. That would be insinuating gender and insinuating God being body. The next question that would probably be raised would be referring to God as the father. In our society males are fathers. It is so hard sometimes to know God is not corporeal, but yet we still refer to God in some bodily image.

via negativa

I find very interesting Aquinas's theory of via negativa and how he describe sGod by describing what he is not. We cannot use our senses to describe him, so i found very clever the way he proposed to describe him with something we know and also know is not him.

Valeria

Thursday, February 24, 2011

God Is Existence

I think that a priori approach to God is a little off track. We have talked about a priori knowledge in International Relations. The professor explained it as ‘assuming there are some things you can’t prove, and you patterned a behavior un-provable; believed to be true’. If you use that definition, you are saying that you can’t prove God’s existence. I feel like God can be proved to humans. We think about God on a daily basis, and many great thinkers throughout history have made reasonable and educated reasons as to why God exists.

Personally, I like the idea of God is existence. I believe in God, and the thought of God being existence makes me feel much better than thinking of him as a big guy on a throne in Heaven. God being existence makes sense to me when you think of the world. Everything exists and most people can’t fathom something creating it all. I think people might can handle existence creating existence better than God creating everything.

When reading Descartes' meditation, the first discusses his doubts. When Descartes talks about his doubts of human senses, I sat back and thought about it. While pondering this idea, I concluded I felt the same doubt at times. While riding home one night earlier this week, the moon was bright, full, and what appeared to be close to the earth. My sisters' first response were, "Look at the moon! Almost seems like we can jump off the roof and hang on.". This reminded me of the meditations. While looking at the moon, one could even make out figures that appeared to be craters. However, everyone knows that the moon is considerably far out of reach. So how is it that it appears so close? I'm sure there is a scientific answer to that question, however, the sense of sight has nonetheless deceived me.
My sight was not the only senses that has deceived me this week, but my hearing also. While on my job, I was continuously deceived by my hearing. My mom has always told me there was a problem with my hearing but I have to side with Descartes again. I repeatedly thought I heard my manager and shift leader calling me. I'm sure everybody can also relate to thinking you heard your phone alerting you of a text message but to no avail. This phenomena kept me going into my pockets for my phone throughout my shift.
Descartes has a point with doubt. Doubting your senses can be easy when one has the aforementioned occurrences.