Showing posts with label Kyle Locascio. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kyle Locascio. Show all posts

Sunday, April 10, 2011

freedom

Satre talks about how we are condemned to be free. He says we are imprisoned because nothing says what we are supposed to do. I completely disagree with this. It's because nothing says what were supposed to do that makes us free, not imprisoned by it. Were able to make our own image of humanity. Condemned makes it seem like we are cursed with it. Satre says we are condemned with choice because he'd rather be told what he's supposed to do. He wants to be given purpose. I say make your own purpose.

Friday, March 18, 2011

3/16/11 class synopsis paper

During class on wensday, we talked about Kant and good will. Kant said to have good will you need to have pure will. Free from outside forces. We brought up Heteronomy vs. Autonomy. Heteronomy is like other law or means to a particular end, an action caused by outside forces. Autonomy is self law, a free agent. The law comes from within me. I give myself the law. We said that good will is the autonomist will. An example of Kant's belief of good will was if you give money to a poor person because of wanting praise for your good deed, it's not virtuous. It has to be good in itself and not for it's consequences. We also brought up categorical imperative vs. Hypothetical imperative. Hypothetical is if you want something, you need to do a certain thing to achieve it. If you get thirsty then you go get a drink. It's a means to a particular end. Categorical is a must. It's an end in itself. It's categorically imperative that you don't kill because you wouldn't think it's ok for everyone else to kill. We talked about The Republic II and how Glaucon radically distrusts everyone. Glaucon tells a story of a man who finds a ring that makes him invisible and even though he's a just man, he will do all of the unjust things he wants because he won't get in trouble. Glaucon believes that the state of nature is that everyones free and that without laws other people will suffer from other people's freedom. If there were no laws, people woudn't be afraid of getting punished for injustice. Glaucon says that the city is built on the idea of radical distrust of radical freedom. The laws are made so people won't have radical freedom. The social contract is radical distrust of freedom. Glaucon said that the unjust person is happier than the just person. We then talked about how Socrates disagrees with Glaucon and believes in radical trust. We aren't complete. We are limited and not free. We become free with others. Trust that others complete you. We talked about how Socrates thought up the ideal city that symbolized the human soul. You made it very clear that the republic II was all about the question of is the just person happier than the unjust person? You brought up an example of marriage contract. Is marriage to complete freedom or limit freedom of spouse? That then brought up the question do laws come about to limit freedom?


Monday, February 28, 2011

descartes

I understand in a way why Descartes believes that God is real, but you can't say you know god is real for certain reasons that aren't concrete proof. We just don't know if he's real or not. And I don't agree with Descartes to doubt the senses. The senses are what help us understand the world and learn from it. And if god is the great deceiver, how can we be sure anything is real? This could all be a trick by God. We truly know nothing.

Monday, February 21, 2011

god

Wensdays class we talked about god and his existence. It's an interesting topic because it's a huge debatable issue. Many religions beileve in god or a god and theres also many people who do not. We can speculate and guess and make theories, but in the end no one knows if god really exists or not. The only things we have about god is written in multiple religious texts that don't seem to have the same views as one or the other, and they tend to even contradict themselves in their own religious books. I grew up with parents that are what I consider to be fairly religious. As I grew up my sister came to question our religion quite a bit. My dad and my sister often get into big debates on the issue of god. I usually just observe on the sidelines and listen to their arguments. My parents never have really asked me about what I think because they are usually too busy debating with my sister about god. I wouldnt really know what to say if they actually asked me. You wanna believe in something because your raised that way but at the same time you question a lot of things about it because you want concrete answers. In the end you need to have concrete faith to believe in things that aren't so easy to prove, comprehend, or understand.

Sunday, January 23, 2011

free will?

the notion of free will vs. determinism is another topic from class that freaks me out. Determinism basically says that there is no free will because everything is pre-determined because of previous events. If everything is already written to happen in a certain way, doesn't that mean that there is no free will? That we are pre-determined to do what were supposed to do? Doesn't that mean that we can't change what's going to happen? if there isn't free will then what's the point in doing anything? You can't change what's supposed to happen. Even if you would attempt to change your "destiny", how would you know what's supposed to happen in order to change it? Maybe it was already determined that you would try to change what you think was your pre-determined path.

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

philosophy

Last class we talked about god and the big bang theory. Our teacher asked questions about god that freaked me out. Not in a way that she was bashing my religion or anything but in a way that just had me asking questions. We always say that god has no beginning so he can't end. How does something not have a beginning? If he wasn't created how did he come to be? He was always here? It's weird to think that he was always there. For how long? Was there anything before God supposedly created everything? And when we started talking about the big bang theory I also started asking questions again to myself. So before the big bang theory there was nothing? I can't comprehend the notion that there was nothing. How can there be nothing? If there was indeed nothing, did time exist? It blows my mind. And then I started to think about dying. What if there is no heaven after death? What if it's just nothing? Is it just blackness? Would it be like sleeping? You'd just be dreaming forever? Or would it be like when your sleeping but you don't dream? But when you sleep and don't dream there's nothing in between. You go to sleep and then you wake up. If you die and it's like going to sleep without dreaming, what would you wake up to? Would you even wake up? Would you just be stuck in that weird spot between sleeping and not dreaming and waking up? This class is definitely blowing my mind so far but it's also opening me up to questions that I hadn't thought about before.