In this class we will ask ‘what is philosophy?’ in the hopes of defending the importance of this discipline for the individual and society. In this endeavor we shall trek through the history of philosophy while unpacking some of the major issues and problems in metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, logic and politics. Furthermore we will address the perennial problems of the good life, personal identity, authenticity and social responsibility.
Wednesday, February 23, 2011
Time
Class Analysis
On Monday February 21, we began the class discussing the play “Waiting For Godot.” We expressed are opinions on what we like and disliked about the play specifically the role of the master and the slave, how the masters power is essentially controlled by the slave, the slave does not need the master, the master needs the slave. We then moved on to the class material advancing from the question, does god exist? To the question, what is god? Starting with Thomas Aquinas(1125-1274), talked about his beliefs in (self evident/ intuitive knowledge of god – too vague) With Aquinas we can not know the essence of god because of his effects or his existence. We can never know the cause unless we know the effects. Two kinds of demonstration, Apriori-through cause itself ( An ontological argument would be attempting to know god in apriorio, the cause itself)
Aposteriori – through the effects(That we can only know what the subject is or what the cause is through the effects) Aquinas gives us his 5 his 5 proofs of god: Mifestor Via, Efficient cause, Contingent and necessary, Gradiation, Design Argument. We can not associate god with us or to something that we know. God is not a rational, or corpeal being, we can not view him in a human or living form. God is everywhere, he does not have a place, he is everyplace. God is Omnipotent, meaning all powerful. “With god nothing is impossible,” Gospel of Luke, and he is Omisciene meaning all knowing. Again we can not think of any of this in a human sense because we will begin to contradict ourselves.
Via Negativa- everything that god knows is fact, it can not be false because what he says is. He is the creator and his speaking cannot but match what is.
God is also eternal, not in the sense of the human linear time, gods being is without successiveness, and he is eternal.
Tuesday, February 22, 2011
2/21 Class Synopsis
For this class, we continued to discuss the difficult issue of proving the existence of God and focused primarily on the arguments proposed by Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274). Beginning with the distinction between faith and reason, Aquinas claimed that there was a fundamental difference separating these two categories of knowledge. This major distinction between belief and knowledge is dependent on the ability to observe and draw conclusions from the effect of a cause, sometimes through scientific inquiry or possibly just through innate knowledge, but we can never have knowledge of what actually causes these effects. Using the example of a triangle, we cannot know what a triangle is without also knowing that it is three-sided, just as we cannot know of the existence of God without first accepting that there is a cause behind the many mysteries of the world.
However, Aquinas did not agree with Plato in assuming that knowledge of God was self-evident or intuitive knowledge, nor did he agree with Anselm’s ontological argument of God being something which nothing greater can be thought. Instead, Aquinas gave two kinds of self-evident (analytic) statements that were “In itself but not to us” and “In itself and to us.” His cosmological arguement explained that since we do not know the essence of God, the proposition is not self-evident to us but must be demonstrated by effects that are more known to us. The ontological argument stated, like before, that we can only know the subject (God, triangle) through its predicate (existence as a whole, three-sided), and also that the effects are not proportionate to the causes as no perfect knowledge of the cause can ever be obtained. These two kinds of demonstrations of God’s existence are known as A Priori (through the cause itself) and A Posterior (through the effect).
To streamline his argument into five major points, Aquinas created the Five Ways which included: (1) Minfestor Via, or the argument of an Unmoved Mover; (2) Efficient Cause, or that nothing can be the cause of itself without having existed first, making God the only uncaused cause; (3) Contingent and Necessary, which states that in nature there are things which can and cannot be generated and it is impossible for these things to always exist, requiring a source to initiate the entire sequence of being; (4) Gradiation, which uses Degrees of Perfection, Goodness and Truth, and Comparative Judgments to imply that there is an existence of the Absolute through the fact that we have comparative thoughts of perfection; and (5) Design Argument, which states that order and finality are doubtlessly the effects of an initial cause.
Regarding the question of what God actually is, Aquinas said that “Having recognized that a certain thing exists, we shall have to still investigate the way in which it exists, so that we may come to understand what it is that exists.” He said that via negativa, we can understand what God is not, namely that he is not corporeal but instead more than a body, and also that God is not potentiality (cause) but Pure Act (cannot be what is or what is not, but a constant state of being – God cannot be but what he is). Instead, Aquinas believed that God is simple and perfect, not just a composition of substance and form, but a fullness of being through one undivided and eternal act. As further evidence that God is not corporeal, we must confront some of the basic questions that would contradict these assertions such as whether or not he would take up space. What body characteristics would he have? Would his omnipresence physically push us away? Alternatively, Aquinas suggested our idea of God should be more abstract, like the concept of twoness, and rooted in the idea that we compose the very body of the bodiless known as God.
Powerless.
Senses
Monday, February 21, 2011
The O'Reilly Argument
I watched a SNL clip with Bill O’Reilly and thought it was a great depiction of his charter. The skit was Bill O’Reilly interviewing President Obama. The clip was obscured with O’Reilly interrupting and insulting President Obama after every question asked. I decided to watch the actual interview with President Obama and Bill O’Reilly and immediately thought of one of our philosophy classes were we talked about valid arguments. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t6HyXCHndmk) He questions Obama on redistributing wealth through out the USA. Bill O’Reilly opens the argument with a editorial piece from The Wall Street Journal that claims President Obama is a “determined man of the left” who gives tax breaks to the middle class. He then claims that the healthcare bill redistributes wealth. Obama replies by saying has not raised taxes once in the last two years, and in reply to healthcare gives example of why the bill was put in place and how it benefits Americans with healthcare and without. Bill O’Reilly replies with the argument that, “a lot of Americans feel hat you are a big government liberal who want to intrude on their personal freedom.” Hasty generalization Bill? Through the entire interview Bill O’Reilly does not give any facts or examples of his criticism, he gives only opinion and generalizations.
Existence of God
