Showing posts with label virtue. Show all posts
Showing posts with label virtue. Show all posts

Monday, February 14, 2011

Virtue in happiness

If happiness is the final and ultimate goal, what is the goal that directly gives us happiness? Is it success? Family? Money? Power? Fame? Can happiness ever really be achieved or can we simply get closer to happiness? Let’s say that happiness is the “fulfillment of one’s function”. Then how do we define our function? Does it change? Is my function today to seek higher education? Once I fulfill that function, does it change to a successful carrier? A wife? Kids? And if our function keeps changing and growing, do we ever truly reach happiness?

I’d argue that our functions do change as we grow and mature. The psychological feeling of happiness comes and goes as we fulfill our current function and accomplish challenges. Could one argue that it is courageous to be happy? I think so. I think it is courageous to fight and accomplish your function and therefore be happy. So a happy person is a courageous person. And to be virtuous in one virtue, you must be virtuous in all virtues. So does that make a happy person a virtuous person?

Are only virtuous men/women happy?

Am I happy?

Sunday, February 13, 2011

Happiness is a Virtue

Socrates believed that happiness is a virtue - and that it is teleological, meaning that happiness is "the end." In order to achieve something called "eudemonia," they need to be an overall virtuous person. Without virtue, one cannot Socrates believed that a person needed to be virtuous in several ways. I agree with this theory, though it is difficult to fathom absolute happiness. However, I think that his theory about happiness has something to do with respecting yourself as a person. I would assume that people with good virtues are happy because they are happy with themselves. Obviously, a life of "eudomonia," would be extremely difficult to achieve, but I do believe that it could be.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Februrary 7, 2011 Class Synopsis

Monday’s class began with an opening subject of virtue. We determined that virtue is a kind of knowledge. We tied this into Plato and Aristotle. Once this was set, questions began to flow. An ever-present subject was the comparison of Plato and Aristotle. Aristotle was a student of Aristotle’s for twenty years at the Academy. Therefore, Aristotle follows platonic ethics. Plato felt that ethics is based on metaphysics. Plato’s metaphysic was that the soul is immortal. He believed in a two-world theory of material versus immaterial. An example by Dr Layne of this theory was that what allows the desk to be a desk is its “deskness”. The essence and purpose of its creation is what makes it a desk, not only its physical make-up. This idea is very important in ethics, the idea that something exists along with the desk. In saying this, we began conversation on idealism. This is the idea that without seeing or experiencing something, we can still know what it is. An example is that, as an idealist, without seeing justice, once can know what justice is. The same concept applies to virtue. Once virtue was mentioned, Dr Layne prompted us to think idealism when we think Plato. To Aristotle, virtue is the fulfilling of one’s function. Then points were made that one can act against knowledge as well as be unhappy under duress.

At the conclusion of these ideas, Dr. Layne moved on into the PowerPoint presentation. The topics covered in the presentation were the life of Aristotle, universals, and physics/metaphysics. Brief points of Aristotle’s life are that he was born in 384 BC and died 322 BC. He was a student of Plato and teacher to Alexander the Great. He was a prolific writer and interested in the imperial investigations. After going abroad to teach Alexander for thirteen years, he is dissatisfied with the state of the Academy. Thus, Aristotle creates the Lyceum, the school in opposition to the Academy of Xenocrates. This was controversial since he was a resident alien so the school was in a public gymnasium. Soon after, Plato dies and things become dogmatic and the Academy is no longer an open-minded eclectic school.

Next came universals. Universals exist only in things, never apart from things. Unlike Plato, we must stud particular phenomena to discover the essence/form residing in them. A common example used by Dr Layne is deskness. The universal of desks is that all desks are similar in that there is the same universal, deskness in each desk.

Seeing that class time was running short, Dr Layne then moved to physics/metaphysics. When asked what metaphysics was, someone answered it was structure. An example given was all is water, meaning all is one. This is a metaphysical statement. A main idea of physics and metaphysics is substance, being a combination of matter (potential) and form (actual). Also discussed at this point was potency connected to rock, human being, acorn, actuality connected kinesis, movement: proper work leading to fulfillment of potency, and entelechia being toward an end/completeness. Lastly, we talked about four causes: material (linked to potency}, formal (linked to entelechia), efficient (cause), and final. Class ended with conversation comparing Aristotle and Plato.

Monday, February 7, 2011

Virtue?

This past week we discussed virtue as knowledge. Socrates said that when committing virtuous acts one must be able to define why these acts are good. Good actions are not virtuous actions until the he who has committed them can explain why they are good. We also spoke about how one person's definition of good may be different than someone else's. This concept can be applied to Fyodor Dostoevski's Crime and Punishment when the main character convinces himself for a short time period that killing the pawn broker lady would be a virtuous act. He explains many reasons why the world would be better off without her and how she was an evil woman. He justifies stealing her money saying that it could be put to good use rather than donated to a church to ensure her place in heaven, which is simply a self righteous thing to do. He believes that he is doing good and can define the virtue in his actions to a certain degree, therefore his actions... at the time at which he was committing them, must have been virtuous.

Sunday, February 6, 2011

Class notes 1/31


Today’s class was all about the Good Life and virtue, from the viewpoint of Socrates.

According to Socrates, happiness is not just a feeling, it’s a sign that we are living the Good Life. Knowledge is equal to virtue for Socrates. The example of Lysis and his parents was given by Plato to demonstrate one of the supporting ideas for knowledge being virtue: “You, yourselves, surely, know that wrong action done without knowledge is done because of ignorance.” That is to say that it is impossible to do good without knowing what good is.

The power of knowledge is such that if one knows what virtue is, it would be impossible for one to act against this knowledge(akrasia); it is impossible to do something bad unless it is done out of ignorance.

But what exactly is good? The three criteria we learned in class for goodness are: coherency with other beliefs, universally applicable, and practicality. The first is self explanatory, but the second is a bit tricky. In order to be universally applicable, a definition for something “good” would need to apply to all instances of goodness. For example, instead of saying what aspects make a few specific acts pious, what makes all pious acts “pious?” The third criteria is just that something has to actually help people in some way in order to be good.

Without virtue and knowledge, life would not be worth living; therefore, Socrates suggests that there ought to be a moral expert. This person would be temperate (a Greek virtue), just, and holy.

Socrates firmly believed (in contrast to Sophist beliefs) that virtues cannot be taught, and there is a bit of relativity in every situation. However, it is a universal desire to seek good. Even when bad actions are taken, the reason behind them is because the bad-doer finds some kind of good or pleasure in the actions. He takes the actions he does because he is looking for what he believes is good.

Even though people may ignorantly do bad things for “good” things, Socrates argues that virtue alone is sufficient to provide happiness. No amount of material goods can make a person happier than living the Good Life can. “Is the King of Persia happy?” Even if everything all the material possessions a person has are lost, his/her goodness is still intact, thus virtue “cannot be harmed either in life or death.” Unfortunately, Socrates never himself mentioned how all virtues are unified.

Socrates is, himself, problematic toward his philosophy. In all accounts of Socrates, he appears to be happy and virtuous, but he claims to be ignorant. If happy=virtuous=knowledgeable, and Socrates=ignorant, but ignorant≠knowledgable, how then can Socrates be so happy? According to Plato’s Republic, virtues are natural work done, and happiness is not a feeling but a fulfillment of what we truly are. As an ignorant being, Socrates’ work (virtue) is to seek knowledge. By living the examined life, Socrates fulfills his natural work and may therefore be happy.